Friends,
A more apt and honest statement regarding how we have ended up so close to World War III hasn’t surfaced until now.
Many of us onlookers watched in horror as seemingly unrelated events were taking place––it was near impossible to make sense of these happenings. Even now looking back, it’s hard to put the details together in a cohesive framework. Yet James Carden has done this work for us.
My self-appointed task was to try to provide business education for the class of Russians who seemed to be most capable of building the “New Russia”. They were the well-educated and desperate young men and women who were reinventing themselves while trying to build small businesses to feed their families.
I am deeply grateful that Carden has put this history together. Read … and marvel at how and why the situation turned out like it has!
All the best,
Sharon Tennison
Center for Citizen Initiatives
American Affairs
May, 2018
The Cold War Culture War
by James Carden
How to explain the current nadir in U.S.-Russia relations?
The litany of oft-cited causes is by now familiar and includes, but is certainly not limited to, the expansion of NATO, the dispute over Kosovo, the American abandonment of the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty, the Russo-Georgian War, and the war in Ukraine, as well as allegations (by both governments1) of election meddling. Over the course of the past decade and a half, U.S.-Russia relations have also been shaped—and not for the better—by the disparate foreign policy approaches taken by American and Russian governments.
Less well known, however, is that America’s growing animus towards all things Russia is also characterized by the hostility borne of a frustrated project of liberal cultural imperialism. In the years following the end of the Soviet Union, the idea that Russia was “ours to lose” gained wide currency in American foreign policy circles. The Clinton administration sought to dismantle the remaining state apparatus of Soviet-era Russia and replace it with a new liberal civil society that took its cues from Washington. In that way, it was believed, Russia could never again pose a challenge to the West.2 Of course, such efforts did not succeed, but our “culture war” approach to foreign policy has only intensified since then. The failure of this project has contributed significantly to the present animus towards Russia and continues to hinder more reasonable diplomatic relations.