Dear CCI Readers,
Never have I had more supporters and detractors than with yesterday’s post regarding the Azov debacle!
Worse still, I quoted Patrick Buchanan (whose humorous pieces I usually enjoy) regarding the Azov waters being like a “Russian lake.” It sounded reasonable at a quick glance… but later, looking at a larger map of the area, I saw that Mariupol was on the shoreline! Was Pat thinking the port was in Eastern Ukraine, therefore it is in Russian-dominated territory? In any case, Maritime Law would have still been the same. By this time, my piece was out. I acted thoughtlessly in an area where I have no expertise! Has this ever happened to you? Argggg! I spent the day reading emails and responding to them. Finally I decided to write to the whole list. I hope the following is understandable.
From a reader came this note that gave me (I think) the essence of the situation. He said: “Sharon, my initial reaction was, likewise, that it isn’t our business (to be policemen). However, Craig Murray, a former British diplomat who is usually very sympathetic to the Russian point of view, says that the Law of the Sea is involved and that in this instance Russia is acting incorrectly:”
https://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2018/12/azov-again/
Murray reports (I have underlined below to accentuate the confusing rights and wrongs):